CageNightly
Fight wire
ResultsUFC 334Gane def. Hokit · DEC (U)13 results · 2 fight clipsResults & highlights

Fight Intelligence · free

Any two fighters, side by side

Win probability from the Cage Nightly Fight Model, skills ranked inside each weight class, numbers adjusted for the quality of the opposition and what to expect if they met tonight.

Fighter A
Fighter B
Payton Talbott
Payton Talbott
BantamweightUFC 6-128 yrs70" reach
Rating 1582 · #11Power striker
42%win chance58%
Fight Model cnm-v1 · neutral corner · if they fought today
Islam Makhachev
Islam Makhachev
WelterweightUFC 18-135 yrs70" reach
Rating 1755 · #1WrestlerSubmission hunter

Different weight classes. Payton Talbott competes at Bantamweight, Islam Makhachev at Welterweight. The model knows nothing about size, so treat the probability as a curiosity, and each fighter's percentiles are against their own division.

Computed from the numbers belowWhat decides it

  1. 01

    Islam Makhachev is the model's pick at 58%, with neither corner assigned.

  2. 02

    Makhachev should find takedowns: about 4.6 per 15 minutes against Talbott's record of defending them, where the UFC average is 1.4.

  3. 03

    On the feet the numbers lean to Talbott: about 3.2 significant strikes a minute expected, against 2.2 for Makhachev.

  4. 04

    Makhachev is 7 years older (35). Compared with their own career, fighters tend to slip below their level from the early thirties; Talbott is 28.

Inside the probabilityWhat moves the number

Bottom lineThe biggest single push is rating gap (elo), towards Makhachev. 6 ingredients lean to Talbott and 4 to Makhachev; on balance Makhachev has the stronger case.

How to read this chart
Each bar
is one ingredient of the Fight Model and how far it pushes the probability, on the log-odds scale. Left = it helps Talbott, right = it helps Makhachev.
Neutral corner:
the UFC usually puts the favourite in red, and the model knows it. Here the number is the average of the two possible corner assignments, so the corner favours no one.
Ingredients overlap,
so a bar is the push on top of everything else, not a full story on its own. How each one is measured is on the method page.
Rating gap (Elo)
Striking output vs what opponents allow
Strikes absorbed vs what opponents land
Age
Takedowns vs what opponents allow
Takedowns conceded vs what opponents land
Control time vs opponents' usual
← helps Talbotthelps Makhachev →

Percentiles inside each weight classSkill profile

Bottom lineEven split: each fighter leads on 4 of the eight skills by ten points or more. Different divisions, so read each side against its own peers.

How to read this chart
Each row
is a percentile from 0 to 100 against the fighters of the same division with at least three UFC fights in the last three years (each fighter against their own division). 50 is the middle of the pack, 90 is the top tenth.
Higher is always better,
defense and durability included: a high striking defense means they absorb fewer strikes than their opponents usually land.
Adjusted for the opposition:
landing five strikes a minute against a fighter who usually concedes two counts for more than against one who concedes six.
96Striking output5
75Striking defense99
44Wrestling92
9Takedown defense96
54Submission threat92
96Power43
85Durability70
87Cardio73

Opponent-adjusted, against the UFC averageIf they met tonight

Bottom lineTalbott should out-land Makhachev on the feet, 3.2 to 2.2 a minute; on the mat Makhachev has the edge, 4.6 takedowns per 15 minutes to 0.0.

How to read this chart
The expected numbers
start from the UFC average of the last five years (4.0 significant strikes a minute, 1.4 takedowns per 15 minutes), add how much more the attacker usually lands than their opponents concede, and how much more the defender usually concedes than their opponents land.
A simple additive estimate,
not a simulation: it does not know who will be on top, or for how long. It tells you which way each phase of the fight leans.
Significant strikes a minute
Talbott3.2
Makhachev2.2
Tick = UFC average 4.0
Takedowns per 15 minutes
Talbott0.0
Makhachev4.6
Tick = UFC average 1.4
Above or below what opponents usually allowTalbottMakhachev
Strikes landed / min+2.0−1.1
Strikes absorbed / min−0.7−2.8
Takedowns landed / 15 min−0.3+1.8
Takedowns conceded / 15 min+1.4−1.4
Control time, share of the fight+4 pts+31 pts

Last five UFC fights against the whole careerForm

Bottom lineStriking margin over the last five against the career, strikes a minute: Talbott −0.4, Makhachev −0.4.

How to read this chart
Career
is every UFC fight with official statistics; Last 5 is the five most recent. The arrow appears when the last five differ from the career by 15% or more (and by a meaningful amount, not 0.1 against 0.0), pointing up when that is good news for the fighter.
Avg opponent rating
is the Cage Nightly rating of the opponents on the night: a fighter whose numbers rise while the opposition gets tougher is improving for real.
Payton TalbottWLWWW
Career (7)Last 5
Sig. strikes landed / min6.15.9•
Sig. strikes absorbed / min3.03.2•
Takedowns / 15 min0.91.3•
Takedowns conceded / 15 min3.33.8▼
Control time22%21%•
Win rate86%80%•
Avg opponent rating15081524•
Islam MakhachevWWWWW
Career (19)Last 5
Sig. strikes landed / min2.32.1•
Sig. strikes absorbed / min1.41.7•
Takedowns / 15 min3.23.2•
Takedowns conceded / 15 min0.10.0•
Control time51%55%•
Win rate95%100%•
Avg opponent rating15731645•

Coming upCompare the next fights